Welcome to the official Pokémon Forums!

Click here to review our official Rules & Guidelines.
[Pokémon TCG Live] Maintenance Notice

Pokémon TCG Live will be offline for maintenance from 16:00 ~ 24:00 (UTC) on February 17, 2026.
Please see the Version 1.35.0 - Patch Notes for more information.

Best starter from each region

2»

Comments

  • Lonestar85
    Lonestar85 Member Posts: 922 ✭✭✭✭
    500 Likes 500 Comments 100 Agrees 25 LOLs

    Warning long post.

    Kanto: Given my extensive experience with Yellow version, I’m inclined to say none of them but for a reason. That reason is that what their strengths happen to be, other Pokémon are simply better at a given role than they are. Take Bulbasaur for example. Grass creams Water, Ground and Rock while being solid Cut users and putting people to sleep. It does get a bit of a boost for Gen 6 onward due to Poison typing beating Fairy but for its primary strengths, it simply falls short. There are no Water/Ground types in Kanto, hence its biggest strength simply isn’t there. Ditto Water/Rock since it only exists on the Fossils and you don’t face them in Gen 1 or any remake for that matter afaik. That means that against the plethora of Water types in Gen 1, Electric is just as effective, if not more so due to Tentacool/Tentacruel being Water/Poison(hence resisting Grass) and Electric isn’t vulnerable to Ice. For putting people to sleep, Bulbasaur gets Sleep Powder way too late and honestly Spore on Paras/Parasect is a more reliable option(also makes a very good Cut user and is an underrated counter to Psychic types). Then you factor in its weaknesses(bad against Flying, weak to Psychic types) and you find Bulbasaur to just be at an unfortunate casualty of the regional Dex. Squirtle’s deficiency is that there are tons of good Water types in Gen 1 and Gyarados is the biggest culprit given you get Magikarp on Route 3. With a bit of grinding, you can have an end-game monster for Misty’s Gym battle. Other options include Starmie, Lapras, Cloyster and Vaporeon. As for Charmander, he gets a rough start with the Gyms and suffers from the fact that Fire types in general are just bad in Gen 1. They even had to give him Metal Claw just to have a chance against Brock for FRLG. Charmander’s lone saving grace is that in Yellow version he is able to take advantage of Charizard’s Flying typing with the Fly HM(in Red/Blue he’s no different than Ninetales for the most part). Finally, Pikachu would have a rough start with Brock but once you get past him, he’s not bad. Yet he can’t evolve so it’s beneficial to dump him in lieu of Magnemite at Rock Tunnel or holding off for Jolteon in Celadon City. If I must pick one… it’s Charmander but by default and it’s only because he has useful utility with HM’s(and I generally don’t use him in lieu of Ninetales).

    Johto: All three are pretty good but I’m going with Totodile on this one. Was my pick in Z-A and he’s solid in Johto.

    Hoenn: Mudkip… the fact he can solo the game is enough

    Sinnoh: Chimchar. Was torn here but I’ll give the edge to the fast Monkey and the fact I prefer Barry with Piplup.

    Unova: I really love Snivy’s design but if I’m being truly honest, it’s Oshawott by a mile.

    XY: Fennekin by default, especially if I play as Serena.

    Sun/Moon: Litten for me… there’s a reason this Cat is a competitive monster when it hits Incinerorar and although I do like Popplio’s Water/Fairy, Alolan Ninetales exists.

    Sword/Shield: Grookey. Got to bang those Drums.

    Paldea: Fuecoco. Was my starter and I see no reason to change it.

  • Eremas
    Eremas Member Posts: 2,485 ✭✭✭✭✭
    1000 Comments 250 Agrees 250 LOLs 250 Likes

    I'm going to give answers because I don't like the meta conversations going on everywhere.

    No1. Kanto=Charmander No2. Johto=Totodile No3. Hoenn=Mudkip No4. Sinnoh=Infernape No5. Unova=Tepig No6. Kalos=Chespin No7. Alola=Litten or Rowlet they are both great No8. Galar=Grookey No9. Paldea=Sprigatito

  • Voltareon2012
    Voltareon2012 Member Posts: 1,507 ✭✭✭✭✭
    500 LOLs 500 Agrees 500 Likes 1000 Comments

    For kanto: Bulbasaur line, I don’t dislike the other two but the two things that really got me into Pokemon were GO and the manga.

    For johto: Chikorita totally. They’re super underrated!

    For hoenn: Totally Sceptile. It’s like a dragon-plant-lizard!

    for sinnoh: I guess Empoleon. Never really liked those three.

    For unova: Dewott. Not the Dewott line, Dewott and Dewott alone.

    For Kalos: Delphox, because I both like foxes and magic.

    For alola: Decidueye. Reminds me of the time I had a depressed phase.

    For galar: CINDERACE ☄️🔥⚽️

    For paldea: Spigatito’s line by far. I like cats and love grass types too!

  • Hades0918
    Hades0918 Member Posts: 9,735 ✭✭✭✭✭
    1,500 Agrees 1,500 Likes 5000 Comments 1,000 LOLs