Chikorita or Oshawott?

Cyndaquil was always my favourite in gen 2, but Chicorita was my second pick. I don't think I've ever actually done a run with Totodile.

It's funny. When gen 5 was first announced Oshawott was considered the goofy looking ugly one that no one would pick. There were web comics making jokes about it. Yet as time has gone on, people seem to have warmed to Oshawott and Tepig has sort of become that.

Snivy was my favourite from the moment the gen 5 starters were announced, but Oshawott grew on me, too. I think I picked it for BW2. I named it "Revolver" because I am hilarious and original.