Nuzlocke Question

theBingoo

so i'm doing a nuzlocke of the original red (and skipping repeats) and accidentally lost a manky on route 5, then i encountered another manky on route 6

would that count as a repeat?

GeneralScout

I'd say that counts as a repeat sadly, since you originally already had a Mankey once in your party. You sadly will have to catch another pokemon. Since this is sort of late however, you probably already moved on.

Stone489990

Yah

D-ManBlue

And honestly- it kind of defeats the purpose of having your Pokemon become unusable when they faint when you can just catch another one to replace it.